The Parenting Post Blog

The Parenting Guilt of Generation X

By Daddy Daze on Monday, July 23, 6:00 am EDT

"Go outside and play."

"But..."

"No 'but.' Go."

I looked at my mother through the dirty screen door. She wore bright yellow elbow-length rubber gloves on her hands and a look of determination on her face — "You are NOT coming back in this house." I turned around and walked into the yard, defeated.

A few hours later, however, when my mother was again talking to me through the screen, the conversation was quite different.

"I said come in here now! It's time to eat"

"No! I want to stay outside."

"David, I am not kidding..."

Such were my childhood summers. I spent a lot of time outside, while my mother was able to get things done in the house, unburdened by a whining, needy kid.

daddy daze

Today, I've got kids of my own, yet the story is different. There's a sense of guilt I feel if I don't spend every waking moment of my kids' day on the floor, actively engaging them and exploiting every educational opportunity that presents itself. I recently read an article that described this phenomenon as a generational thing, more prevalent among parents in their thirties than previous generations.

Call it The Parenting Guilt of Generation X.

What's going on, Gen X'ers? Is it the parenting shows on TV? The magazines? The repeated viewings of Reality Bites?

I don't know when it happened, but at one point someone impressed upon me the notion that my kids' development and education is all-important, and something that I should ensure at any cost — even my own happiness. "Parenting is about sacrifice," is the mantra I've somehow gotten in my head. But how much?

My mother had no problem letting the kids play on their own, so why can't I?

Anyway, 30-somethings, tell me I'm not alone. Do you struggle with this as well? Life was so much easier when we were wearing Dr. Martins and black T-shirts, listening to The Smiths, and sulking. Ah, the good old days.

‾‾‾‾‾

Visit Daddy Daze's personal blog


Member Comments
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 9:12 am
I remember those days when kids could think for themselves and play on their own. Hmmmm, I feel the same guilt but have experimented in seeing what happens when I step back and just watch them play and I like it! But not as much as our parents did...I still like to be in the middle of a lot of things just becuase it's fun and it makes us close. Somewhere in between our parents days and ours maybe?


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 9:31 am
During our years as kids technology wasn't where it is now, so people actually worked from 9-5 instead of 24/7. Athletics for kids began in highschool, at least really seriously, now? They begin practically from birth. Time is spoken for in a different way than ever before and parents feel the crunch on family time. Parents who work and parents who are home feel the guilt equally- guilt-0-meters are overrunning!


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 9:57 am
We were kicked out of the house during the summer too. If we came back in, we got saddled with chores. My friends and I developed the greatest sense of imagination from those summers. I some times feel like I deprive my kids of that because they don't get bored and figure it out on their own like we did. I am always there to suggest what to do next. Of course, this means my house is not as clean as my mom's was!


 cbs's picture
cbs
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 11:25 am
Both my parents were teachers so during the summer we hit road and traveled all over. That's the one thing I wish I could give my daughter. Time to be free to go and do what we want as a family. She has fun at camps and visiting family,but it's all structured. It's a tough balance, teaching a kid to entertain themselves and still spending time w/them playing in so few hours. There's always guilt about something!


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 12:40 pm
I feel the guilt too! I used to even believe I would be one of those parents who could play for hours on the floor, happily contributing to the child's growth and development. However, two minutes of my daughter directing me to "say this, now I say this, now you say..." and I want to toss the horses/dolls/animals out the window. And I feel bad if she's outside alone and I'm inside-even though she's having a blast.


 Paul K.'s picture
Paul K.
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 12:44 pm
You're not alone. Having only one child and no kids his age on our block, I have found I'm my son's #1 playmate. For the most part I enjoy it, but struggle with all of the things that I'm not getting done around the house as well. Mostly, I've found that if I let him lead the play (within reason), then it still seems to stimulate him and challenges him to grow.


 Maureen B's picture
Maureen B
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 1:49 pm
I feel guilty if I am not out there, playing with them. Maybe that is because if I am not out there with them, I worry, even though we have a fenced back yard, about someone coming to get them (they are 5 and 3). Maybe as they get older....


 Joy's picture
Joy
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/23/2007 at 4:35 pm
My two boys (3 1/2 and 5) love to play together. Inside, outside, on the computer, pretty much anything. I also have two girls (almost 2 and newborn) so I appreciate so much that the boys entertain themselves well. BUT I feel terribly guilty about it, just like you said, that I should be involved every minute. I shoot for balance - time reading & playing with them and time for them to play without me.


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/26/2007 at 8:04 am
There is so much pressure on parents today, in terms of educating and stimulating your child. Personally I encourage my kids to have time playing on their own. I think its important for their independence and for developing their own imaginations. I must confess, I regularly send my kids out to play. I don't think it hurts! Elissa http://www.parentingtodayonline.com


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/26/2007 at 4:26 pm
Dave - I would advise staying close. This is what happens when I miss one little waking moment of my kids' day ..., www.womanwifemom.blogspot.com Pay backs are a bitch!! LOL.


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/26/2007 at 4:26 pm
http://www.womanwifemom.blogspot.com


 Melissa (Dave's sister)'s picture
Melissa (Dave's sister)
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/26/2007 at 10:37 pm
Dave's a great Dad. The kids love playing with him because he went to whatever the goofy school it is Daddy's go to that makes them so much fun. My Dad was always fun like that. Grace and William are also able to play independently and have fun. I can't imagine what a tough call it is when trying to find the balance. All I know is that you have 2 great kids.


re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/27/2007 at 7:43 am
Awww


 Erin's picture
Erin
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
7/29/2007 at 7:00 pm
All of us like 'alone time'. I think it is good to let them feel that out a little too. Like you say, sometimes they are perfectly happy playing with a stick from the ground by themselves...see, you have a better handle on it than you thought. Ha Ha.


 Lucia's picture
Lucia
re: The Parenting Guilt of Generation X
9/7/2007 at 4:38 pm
This is interesting to me as I want to do my dissertation on this subject. Why do you think some parents feel guilt about not getting involved in the play and others don't ?


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

All submitted reviews are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.


advertisement



Parenting Post Bloggers

Parenting Post Categories

About This Blog

Our favorite bloggers savor the precious few sweet moments of parenthood.


Recent Comments


Recent Posts




Birthday Parties

31 Amazing Birthday Cakes

Blog: The Split

Evie: "Should I think about dating? I know there's no exactly right or wrong answer, but I'm wondering: Can you be separated and single at the same time?" Updated frequently.

Blog: Family Budget Boot Camp

Denene at My Brown Baby: "Even if Angelina wanted to find new ways to care for and style her African baby girl's hair, surely, she'd be at a loss, 'cause I sure am. And so we are left to our own devices. Black child hair care ain't easy." Updated Frequently!

Toys of the Year

We're giving away over $900 worth of the best toys! Enter BOTH giveaways once a day until December 14
Facebook

Overheard on Facebook

Donna: "I also got pregnant while planning my wedding. She was four months old when we said I do and I wouldn't have had it any other way :)"