The Parenting Post Blog

Lions and Tigers and Siblings, Oh My!

By Rocks In My Dryer on Monday, October 27, 10:49 am EDT

One of my dearest hopes for my kids is that they grow up to be best friends. It’s my favorite mental picture, the idea of them gathered together long after I’m gone, laughing and looking out for each other. But right now? Today? In this world of shared rooms and shared clothes and shared toys and shared parents? There are days when the moments of peaceful siblinghood feel very far away.

I know, of course, that sibling rivalry is a normal phenomenon. Having more than one not-yet-fully-mature little human living in close quarters with other not-yet-fully-mature little humans will, understandably, breed some tension. I don’t think testy sibling relationships are necessarily an indicator of troubled relationships with siblings in adulthood. (If they were, I would still be holding a grudge against my little brother for answering the telephone with an Australian accent whenever one of my friends called during the entire year of 1988. I am not AT ALL still peeved over that, and I only mention it very publicly at Parenting’s website as an illustrative point, and not AT ALL because I am, in any way, gaining some satisfaction by getting him back for that at this very moment.)

Where was I?

Oh, yes, sibling rivalry.

Like I said, I think a fair dose of it is fine, though I don’t think that’s an excuse for parents to let it slide. I think a smart parent will acknowledge sibling tussles as developmentally normal, but still use them as a chance to teach kids about getting along. In our family, we have a whole list of strategies for reminding our little people that unkindness won’t be tolerated around here. These ideas include, but are not limited to:

Making them stay and work it out. Often, I’ll send them to a private, confined spot (a bench or a bed, perhaps), and tell them they can argue as long as they’d like, but nobody is getting up until they’ve worked out a solution that is agreeable to both of them. It’s amazing how fast they start negotiating, and it teaches them independent conflict resolution.

Requiring the fighters to sit together and holding hands. This is especially helpful when the fight in question is over a specific spot on the couch, a frequent hot-button around here. Best of all, what started as a fight quickly evolves into gales of laughter at the ridiculousness of the whole thing.

Writing sentences. Oh yes, we do. This provides some excellent cool-down time to stop and gather their thoughts. My husband’s favorite sentence to assign is “I am my brother’s keeper.”

Doing a sibling’s chores. This one is especially effective for a kid who is repeatedly picking on a sibling. If you are going to bully someone in this house, be prepared to tackle the chore list of the person you’re bullying. Works like a charm.

Positive reinforcement works, too. When I see a kid serving his sibling, I lavish praise. And occasionally, at random times, I’ll ask them to tell me something kind they’ve done for each of their siblings that day. They know to expect that question occasionally, and they actually take pride in being able to supply an impressive answer.

Most of all, I remind them regularly that these are long-haul relationships. The annoying little brother who just broke their Lego tower will be best man at their wedding someday. Despite a few bumps in the road, I think they’re getting it.

What about you? What’s your best strategy for dealing with sibling fights?

_____

Visit Rocks in My Dryer's personal blog.


Member Comments
good ideas
10/27/2008 at 5:43 pm
I have that same dream for my three daughters, and I love the strategies you've shared.


Sibling Rivalry
10/27/2008 at 6:50 pm
As a mother of two teens still living in the house, I have to agree. It would be nice to think the two of them will eventually be friends. So far, they seem to fight like cats and dogs. My oldest child, who is now out of the house and in college, got a long just fine with both of them. I guess some personalities are just fire and oil, even in families. totaltransformationreview1@yahoo.com http://thetotaltransformation.tumblr.com/


Heather's picture
Heather
Even though my little sister
10/27/2008 at 8:27 pm
Even though my little sister left my beloved doll house out in the rain when she was 4 (I've been over that one for weeks...) we are best friends now. It literally happened in an instant the day she gave birth to her daughter and all of her beautiful, tattooed edges softened. It took a very turbulent 26 or so years, but she was worth waiting for! And she has totally forgiven me for "diverting" her allowance by selling her an invisible unicorn (more than once).


Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
Great Ideas!
10/27/2008 at 9:28 pm
Thanks for the good ideas. I especially like the one about doing the other one's chores. Thanks for sharing!


Siblings
10/27/2008 at 11:02 pm
I like the idea of doing the siblings chores. My brothers used to pick on me like crazy. My favorite story is when my parents wanted to see if my brother was mature enough to own a BB gun. Well he took his friends gun and shot me in the butt with it. My parents bought him one that Christmas. =/ Another time my parents put my brother into karate and he used it to beat me up. we're best of friends now. LOL


Great article
10/27/2008 at 11:49 pm
I enjoyed your article. We must be getting some of the same advice somewhere as I try to use the same techniques you mentioned. The holding hands and working it out seems to cool things down quickly! Doing the other's chores to me, anyway, shows them, if you hurt some one somehow, you have to pay it back....to try to make it up. One thing I tell my oldest, who's next sister is only 21 months younger than her, but they are polar opposites....in 20 years, when you have something really really good happen or really really bad happen- you're going to want to call your sister (just like I do) and the way you treat her now could influence if she decides to answer the phone or just let it ring. It makes her think for a good 30 seconds anyway....


I adore the idea of having
10/28/2008 at 2:31 am
I adore the idea of having the picker doing the chores of the pick-e (picky?). And I really should start with the sentences. Thanks for some good ideas.


What works for me...
10/28/2008 at 9:11 am
"The annoying little brother who just broke their Lego tower will be best man at their wedding someday." Oh my word. Thanks for making me cry this morning, Shannon! We've also had the brothers march around the dining room table holding hands and saying, "I love you because you're my brother." They end up running and laughing around lap two. I think one big thing is that we expect them to get along. So many people dread having more than one or two kids simply because they expect it to be trouble. We introduced the new baby as "our" new baby, not "my" new baby. Even from when the new baby is itty bitty we lavish praise on them for helping, making the baby smile, sharing toys with the baby etc. Right now my kids are 8, 5, 3 and 20 months and honestly their favorite friends are each other. Also, and this sounds like a side note when it is really the entire focus. When we found out we were pregnant with our first we started praying earnestly for his future sibling relationships. And each time we were pregnant after that we continued that prayer.


Thanks for the great ideas!
10/28/2008 at 10:57 am
Thanks for the great ideas! I just LOVE your blog, Rocks In My Dryer. I linked to this article on my blog www.educationmom.com.


edj's picture
edj
Great ideas!
10/28/2008 at 3:40 pm
You have great ideas! We've tried some of them. Once Donn made Elliot wash Ilsa's feet after he'd been particularly mean. They giggled their way through it and by the end were fast friends again.


Interesting Ideas - 1 concern!
10/28/2008 at 5:06 pm
OK, so I have to voice this because the English teacher in me is screaming out to be heard. While I thought most of your ideas for getting siblings to work out problems were great (and several of them ones I'm going to tuck away myself for future reference), one of them made me cringe. Please don't use writing as a punishment. I am not saying this as a parent but as a teacher. Writing is one of those skills that sadly can be very difficult to develop in children. And to use it as a punishment really doesn't help. Now don't get me wrong. I've seen this used as a tool in terms of telling a child to go sit and write out some of his/her thoughts about what's going on, how s/he might be able to work towards a solutions, yadda, yadda. That's great. That's constructive, is helping the child learn to think for himself, process a situation and all that. But lines...not so much. Forcing someone to write for the sake of just repeating one thought...all that does is focus a child on how irritating the act of writing is. The words themselves tend to lose their meaning. My husband used to work at a children's psychiatric hospital, and that was one of their "instructional tools" was making these kids write lines when they broke the rules. End result, he's had those same kids who were supposed to be trying things like journeling, etc as tools to work on their thinking and as a positive form of expression (as opposed to the violence or other behaviors they had been using) tell him that they hated writing, especially after having to write lines for being bad. Just my two cents (for whatever it's worth!). Don't mean to offend or criticize anyone!


Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
On that note..
12/2/2008 at 2:42 pm
That's very true, why make something you want them to love, to be something they want to avoid: punishment. If affection is being used as a form of punishment then it can work in an adverse way as well. My mom used a similar tactic: we had to sit on a chair together or hold hands. Or it'd be a quick thing like "did you just hit her? go give her a hug and say you're sorry!" I think the result was less hugging among my siblings and me and more resentment for hugs/handholding with eachother. Probably because we'd be so angry in that moment when we had to do it. We couldn't wait to split from that chair! We're older now in our early, mid, and late 20s. When we see eachother (which is often! :)), we hug because we miss eachother but it's really kind of awkward between us.. because we didn't like doing it before.


Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
House Rules
10/29/2008 at 5:06 pm
Our rule for couch space is "you move you feet you lose your seat". If one gets up for whatever reason they cannot expect to get their same spot back on the couch...there is no saving seats. As a mom of 4 kids ages 16, 13, 8, and 4, you have to be creative. I love the idea of making them hold hands...that one I am putting away for future use....maybe I will make them do it the next time we are out on a shopping trip from hell.....


Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
Sibling Rivalry advice
10/31/2008 at 11:53 am
I just found a great CD to deal with sibling rivalry issues. It is from Love and Logic. It gives great advice about letting them work it out themselves...it has been a great help with my family! You can find it here: http://www.loveandlogic.com/ecom/p-328-sibling-rivalry-strategies-for-saving-your-sanityand-teaching-your-kids-how-to-get-along.aspx


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

All submitted reviews are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.


advertisement



Parenting Post Bloggers

Parenting Post Categories

About This Blog

Our favorite bloggers savor the precious few sweet moments of parenthood.


Recent Comments


Recent Posts




Birthday Parties

31 Amazing Birthday Cakes

Blog: The Split

Evie: "Should I think about dating? I know there's no exactly right or wrong answer, but I'm wondering: Can you be separated and single at the same time?" Updated frequently.

Blog: Family Budget Boot Camp

Denene at My Brown Baby: "Even if Angelina wanted to find new ways to care for and style her African baby girl's hair, surely, she'd be at a loss, 'cause I sure am. And so we are left to our own devices. Black child hair care ain't easy." Updated Frequently!

Toys of the Year

We're giving away over $900 worth of the best toys! Enter BOTH giveaways once a day until December 14
Facebook

Overheard on Facebook

Donna: "I also got pregnant while planning my wedding. She was four months old when we said I do and I wouldn't have had it any other way :)"