The Parenting Post Blog

Fear of Death: How to Talk About it With Your Pre-schooler, Even When You Don't Want To

By Bilingual in the Boonies on Friday, June 12, 10:50 am EDT

Mothering is of extremes.

Last week, my daughter put on a shiny gold tutu and melted my heart as she showed off her ballet moves and her fabulous, free-style "wiggle-wiggle-pop."

Then, for a few nights going she has broken my heart when she has cried and told me she is afraid of dying.

A mother isn't supposed to imagine her child dying, nor feel helpless about her child's fear of dying.

It has happened at bedtime. She wants the light on. She never used to. She tells me she is now afraid of the dark. The sobbing begins and she tells me she doesn't want to die.

It took me by surprise the first time it happened and I fumbled through it.

You're not going to die for a very, very, very long time. It is natural to be afraid of dying. It is sad when we don't see people we love anymore. But, everything in the world dies and yes, it would be nice if it didn't. The people we love always are in our hearts, no matter what. You're only 5, no way you're going to die anytime soon.

At that last one, I nearly busted out crying too. Crush that thought, crush that thought, crush that thought, my own brain screamed.

I asked my Mothering Brain Trust (my mom's group) about this and they suggested conversations I had already had. OK, good. I'm not a total fumbler. Of course, except for one key thing: Where is she getting this? What is bringing it up? I didn't ask. I forgot. Wuh.

I looked at Dr. Spock's Baby and Child Care. The good doctor said no sugar-coating it. Such an episode too, is a good opportunity to talk about family beliefs about death. I have done that. I told her we never are truly apart. Forever and ever.

She has bought none of it and I really, really want to tell her that by the time she's my age some downloadable app will be invented that will keep her wiggle-wiggle-popping until the end of days.

I have encouraged her to turn her mind toward other things when thoughts of death creep in. I told her she is stronger than her thoughts and that focusing on gratitude for the day, for our loved ones, for the cool stuff we'll do tomorrow, always helps.

She looked at me sideways.

There was no death talk at last night's tuck-in. What a relief. But, if I know my kid, the topic will be back.

Until then, this quote by Selma Faiberg in the Spock book, will help me: ''The future mental health of a child does not depend on the presence or absense of ogres in his fantasy life. It depends on the child's solution to the ogre problem.''

So tell me, how best to help her find a solution?

Visit Bilingual in the Boonies and Los Pollitos Dicen.


Member Comments
You said all the right things
6/17/2009 at 2:40 pm
I also like to point out the reasons that statistically, some people die. I talk about illness in old age, staying healthy, wearing seat belts, etc. My kids' quickly turned from fear of themselves dying to fears of my husband and I dying. I explained to that that although it was possible that it could happen at any time, that mommy and daddy, again, wear seat belts, we try to eat well and exercise, we go to the doctor for check-ups and take our medicine when we need to, and we always use safety equipment for sports or work. I think letting them know that there are some ways to be proactive instead of reactive can help. And I think you're right...this is all tied to the other fear kids have: "Who will take care of me after I die?" There is an feeling that "If I'm not here, I must be somewhere, and when I'm there, who will take care of me?" That's a tricky question, but according to religion or other beliefs, I think that's another question that should be answered as best we can. Ultimately, I think little kids want to know that they will be in some place of love and safety, and I'm personally okay with stories that help answer that fear of being alone in a way that children can understand according to their age and stage. Kids naturally begin to move from literal to figurative as they get older, and any explanations can be expanded upon or re-visited as the questions get revisited and the more simple answers of younger childhood are not enough. Honestly, I'm revisiting many of these questions myself at 43 years old.


You did well
6/19/2009 at 1:58 pm
This is so hard. We lost a baby at full-term just 2 weeks before our daughter turned 3. At that time, her questions were along the lines of, "Can we get another baby?" and "Can we go up to heaven in an airplane to see him?" A year or two later the questions turned into, "What happens after I die?" and "Please don't bury me in the ground" and "I don't want to die" fears and screaming sessions. So, so hard. We told her about heaven (though we're not sure what we believe in the respect, we do go to church and have a somewhat shaky religious foundation), promised her she wouldn't die for a long, long time, and that there are people who will take care of her if anything should happen to us. It's not easy. Whatever we said worked, however, at least for now, though I anticipate more questions eventually. I have a book that I just love, called The Next Place, by Warren Hanson--it is just phenomenal, at least for me. (Though it makes me cry every time.) Gorgeous pictures, reassuring tone, though no "answers." That's not a solution for you, I know, but just keep being reassuring. I think it's all one can really do.


Helen's picture
Helen
My 5 year old's fear of death
7/26/2009 at 11:24 am
I found your post googling "childhood fear of death" because my five yo daughter is doing exactly the same thing and it is incredibly painful. I want to take the fear away and i blame myself because i explained too much about death when her grandad (whom she seldom saw) died. It's so awful, isn't it? She cries so hard and says things like "Can I be the same box as you" and "Will you be able to cuddle me when I'm dead" and no amount of teling her how far away it is or that she'll understand more when she's older is gonna help this. She cannot concieve of not existing (and we have no belief in an afterlife)and to her perception at some point she will die and either be burnt or buried forever and she thinks she will be aware of this and it's terrifying. Has your daughter always been sensitive? We have to keep mine away from the news or talk of disibility or we have floods of tears and i end up inventing another "chapter" to whatever she's heard that makes it turn out well! I worry because my mother and grandfather have suffered from mental health problems and mood disorders. I don't but i think that's partly cos I'm really determined not to having had to be a child carer to my mother! I really hope my little girl is not going to have these sorts of problem but am probably getting ahead of myself. The advice I have read in the past couple of days about this is that it is not uncommon and does usually pass in weeks or months, that it's often a sign of high intelligence because the childs cognitive understanding exceeds their emotional maturity and that the best thing to do is to explain the biological facts of death because the child will probably not be asking about the philosophical or spiritual facets of it. That does not really tell us how to reassure our little girls who have just realised they are not immortal and are frightened about it because it is a frightening realisation. On the plus side I personally remember learning about death and feeling cold and numb inside (I cannot say for how long. My mother didn't notice) but then suddenly realising that it takes so long to grow up (in a childs mind) that it was as though it would never happen and genuinely getting over it just like that and never worrying about it again. I've noticed it's been several weeks since you posted that. How is your daughter now? Mine first learned of death in February and was upset then but it's been coming and going since with this last episode being the most upsetting. I think that is because her vocabulary has just really taken off tho so she can express her feelings that much better. Hope your little girl has come to terms with it better now.


Mark's picture
Mark
fear of death
8/28/2009 at 6:22 am
I have come across your discussion in response to a Google search. I did the search because my eight year old daughter has recently expressed the very same thoughts. We have been aware for some time that she has not been totally at ease with going to bed - it's actually quite hard to get her to sleep in her own room, and when she does she needs the radio or some other sound, or a light in the hall etc. And just very recently she actually articulated very similar fears to those mentioned above. The fears are not that she might die in the night, or get knocked down or whatever - you can re-assure against these fears as recommended by Jozet above with talks about safety and healthy lifestyle. But I think what we are facing here is the fear that is engendered when one realises that, come what may, one is going to die. How do you reassure against that? This development is particularly painful because I have suffered from this all my life. Though I have learned to "Crush that thought, crush that thought, crush that thought," it is something that I have had to do throughout life, and I know that it is always there, ready to pounce and assail me. I suppose this has many of the characteristics of a phobia and would like to be cured - but most phobias are cured by learning that the object is actually harmless. My biggest fear at the moment is that my daughter is showing the first signs of the same long lasting condition. Your posts have reassured me to some extent that it may be a part of natural development. Does anyone know where the best place to go would be for expert professional advice on the subject?


Based on your own advice to
9/23/2009 at 4:39 pm
Based on your own advice to your daughter "I told her she is stronger than her thoughts and that focusing on gratitude for the day, for our loved ones, for the cool stuff we'll do tomorrow", I think you are doing just fine on your own. I can tell that you are very well thought out in what you choose to say to her. Always trust your motherly instinct and I bet that you deal with these kind of tough questions better than most.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

All submitted reviews are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.


advertisement



Parenting Post Bloggers

Parenting Post Categories

About This Blog

Our favorite bloggers savor the precious few sweet moments of parenthood.


Recent Comments


Recent Posts




Blog: The Daily Fave

Shawn: "Sure, it helps to know what a mucus plug is, but mostly guys need books that offers simple, streamlined, practical info that doesn't get bogged down with a lot of 'medical diagrams' or 'compound sentences.' Well have I got the book for you, Pops." Updated frequently.

Blog: The Parenting Post

Mighty Maggie: "I have been in charge of the family finances for about a year now and I STILL DON'T KNOW WHAT I AM DOING." Updated Daily!

The Best Toys of 2009

We're giving away over $900 worth of toys! Enter BOTH giveaways once a day until December 14
Birthday Parties

31 Amazing Birthday Cake Designs

Sweet! The easiest, cutest cakes for boys and girls