The Daily Fave Blog

Why Do Moms Dump on Each Other?

By Lauren at Parenting.com on Thursday, July 2, 3:12 pm EDT

 

 

The other day my co-worker was standing on a street corner with her two-year-old, who was strapped into her stroller. Her daughter had managed to wriggle her little arm out of the shoulder strap, when a woman swept up to her with a worried look on her face, squealing, "She's standing up! She's standing up!" My co-worker looked down to see her daughter sitting, but with one free arm waving in the air. No danger in sight. Why the freak-out from this bystander?

I have yet to meet a mother without a similar story -- one mother puts on her Judgy McJudgy pants and makes a critical statement about another mother's parenting habits. "Your baby looks cold." "Has your son had a nap today?" "She's standing up! She's standing up!" We generally don't show this much interest in each other's lives. Why, when it comes to parenting, do we feel free to distribute our opinions, criticisms, and reservations about something that's none of our business?

Judith Warner touched upon this in a recent article in the NYTimes, Insult and Injury. It's a good read because these stories are generally entertaining, but there is also an important question at stake: why do moms dump on each other so much? Has a mom every said a snippy comment to you about your parenting skills? Have you ever found yourself guilty of this crime?

Plus:
How to Handle Annoying Advice
20+ Of the Greatest Mom Tips Ever
Getting Over New-Mom Guilt


Member Comments
Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
Judgy McJudy Grandma-Pants
7/6/2009 at 5:00 pm
I had this happen to me recently at the airport, twice! I'm a young new mom and I recently flew with my son and my husband to Salt Lake, a short 2.5 hour flight from Seattle. I had two older women make remarks to my face!! The first asked me if I really thought it was a good idea to fly with such a small baby (10 months at the time) during the swine flu scare. The next "preachy" comment came from a woman in her early sixties I'm guessing...well here's the scenario. My family and I were sitting waiting to line up for boarding an older man (65-70ish) who seemed to be differently abled came to say hello to my son. We spoke to him for a while and he reached out to shake my sons hand, and did so before I could politely ask him not to. After he left I grabbed my purse to get my hand sanitizing wipes when the woman behind and kiddy corner from us leaned over and said "You know, you really shouldn't let people touch your children these days." Whilst shooting rude glances towards the aforementioned man and his caregiver. I really thought she was out of line...and VERY rude! I can take care of my own without the comments of strangers! To top it all off we ate dinner at a restaurant in the Seattle airport on our return flight and right in the middle of dinner my son vomited all over himself, the table, his dinner and the floor! Aaaand he had a massive BM that went up his back right before the vomit. The waitress was so helpful and really understanding. Yet, I got glares from at least 3 women on my way out the back of the restaurant towards the bathroom to clean up...no one said anything to me, but really?! How could I have controlled something like this? To these glare giving women, I hope the scene ruined your dinner! Sincerley, Anonymous in Seattle


Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
Civic Responsibility vs Arrogant Accusation
7/6/2009 at 11:05 pm
I recently moved to Chicago where many people seem to think it's their business to tell you how to handle your kid. One rainy day, I was accused of some degree of child abuse four times on my way home from picking up my son from daycare! One guard even accused me of slamming my son's head through a large turnstile at the train station. He was perfectly happy, and she hadn't even seen us go through it! Then another woman saw me struggling to prevent my son from kicking off the rain jacket for the stroller and said "your son is getting wet!" in an accusatory tone as if I weren't aware of that. She could clearly see that my son was perfectly happy (as long as the rain jacket wasn't spoiling his view). This never happened in San Francisco. When I first arrived in Chicago with my son he was an infant and it was a very cold week in April. We didn't have appropriate clothing, so we just layered everything on him and covered him with blankets over the Bjorn. In the two block stretch from my house to the train station a handful of people told us that his foot (covered in three pair of socks and at least a couple of sleepers) was coming out of the blanket. I thought that it was charming. I thought it showed civic responsibility that everyone would take it upon themselves to make sure that the child was warm.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

All submitted reviews are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.


advertisement



Daily Fave Categories

About This Blog

Our team of Editors share their stories, review cool stuff, and discuss the rewards and challenges of parenthood.


Recent Comments





Blog: The Daily Fave

Shawn: "Sure, it helps to know what a mucus plug is, but mostly guys need books that offers simple, streamlined, practical info that doesn't get bogged down with a lot of 'medical diagrams' or 'compound sentences.' Well have I got the book for you, Pops." Updated frequently.

Blog: The Parenting Post

Mighty Maggie: "I have been in charge of the family finances for about a year now and I STILL DON'T KNOW WHAT I AM DOING." Updated Daily!

The Best Toys of 2009

We're giving away over $900 worth of toys! Enter BOTH giveaways once a day until December 14
Birthday Parties

31 Amazing Birthday Cake Designs

Sweet! The easiest, cutest cakes for boys and girls